Online ordering powered by Seamless
891 8th Avenue (8th Ave. Between 53rd St. & 54th St.)(212) 582-8333
Minimum order of $10.00 is required for delivery
Delivery estimate is 25-40 min (more info)
Seamless allows you to enjoy convenient online ordering from the best local restaurants. If you're ordering for the first time, start your order by entering your address to the right. Return users log in here.
Minimum order of $10.00 is required for delivery
Delivery estimate is 50 - 65 min (more info)
Print this menu
Served w/ Crisp Iceberg Lettuce, Holland Tomatoes, Bermuda Onion & Home-Made Coleslaw
Welcome to Pick A Bagel--home of the delicious hand rolled bagels. We sell tasty, homemade, freshly baked bagels, muffins, croissants and more, with no preservatives, no oil and the highest quality ingredients available.
We are conveniently located throughout New York City, and we are available from 6:00 am to 11:30 pm for all your bagel, bakery and restaurant desires. Whether you are a local resident in the New York City area or ordering from a corporate office or business, Pick A Bagel is your one stop shop for all your bagels, bakery, restaurant needs: Tossed Salads made to order, Paninis, over stuffed sandwiches, homemade soups, no carbs lettuce wraps, desserts and much more!
We at Pick A Bagel know that planning a party whether it’s a corporate gathering, business meeting, surprise parties or other occasion – each is important, if not necessary, but can also be time consuming and a bit of a hassle. Let us take some of the burden off of you! Our staff is here to cater and please you: our most important customer.
Healthy Start—Good Morning NY – Fat free yogurt, fresh berries and granola is your way to start the day
Paninis—Assortment of overstuffed European bread sandwiches grill pressed to ensure heavenly taste
Toss Your Own Salad—Pick your salad ingredients out of our rich selection, add your favorite dressing and we’ll toss it or chop it so you’ll get the salad you craved the whole time
Traditional Hot Pastrami and Corned Beef—Our steamed corned beef and pastrami will defiantly leave you with a taste to remember. Served with your choice of toppings on the type of bread of your choice you just cannot go wrong
Don’t skip our famous Smoked Fish Variety whether it is a sandwich or a platter we are here to make sure you will love this NY experience—Smoked sable, Nova Scotia salmon, smoked white fish accompanied by our full line of assorted cream cheeses and of course our freshly baked hand rolled bagels.
Not in our delivery zone? Please visit our other Pick A Bagel locations around Manhattan:
Pick A Bagel (2nd Ave)
1475 2nd Avenue
Pick A Bagel (3rd Ave)
297 3rd Avenue
Pick A Bagel (North End)
102 North End Street
Pick A Bagel (Upper East)
1101 Lexington Avenue
0 to a 100 real quick!
Delivered my food on a sunday at prime time under the delivery estimate. Lox are too good and I tried getting their mushroom barley soup but it was sold out! One of my favorites
Posted a year ago by Naty A.
Always great whether ordering online or walking in. Staff is on par with the quality of the bagels/food
Posted a year ago by gary m.
They screw up the order far too often.
Posted a year ago by Michael L.
consistently yummy and fresh food
Posted a year ago by kristina g.
Food is always great. Order almost every weekend when i'm in town. Not sure what I would do without my "go to" bagel store.
Posted a year ago by Eric P.
35-50 minutes? more like 90 minutes!!!!
Posted a year ago by Daniel S.
The few times I've ordered has been a big success. It comes in a timely fashion, the order is correct, and the food tastes great!
Posted a year ago by Monica E.
amazing sandwiches, fast delivery
Posted a year ago by anna w.
Always quick delivery
Posted a year ago by Jodie G.
Disappointing. Not much smoked salmon, extra charge for toasting!!! and did not include all the toppings I had ordered and paid for.
Posted a year ago by Maria F.
bacon egg and cheese hangover sandwiches - do it! expect a long delivery wait on the weekends though, plan ahead and order seamless as soon as you wake up with your hangover and you will be fine.
Posted a year ago by jane k.
Bagels are fresh and warm!
Posted 2 years ago by janet f.
Had to stop using for daily delivery because of consistent delivery issues. Always late, nothing special about bagels.
Posted 2 years ago by Mariam E.
I live in the neighborhood and like the bagels here enough where I want to make it my go-to place to order bagels in the morning for my kids (we'd probably average a dozen or two a week--I have four kids!). But with 1hr delivery times, it's just not practical especially on school days. I hope they improve this. Until then, I'll go back to ordering from our other bagel place that delivers in 20 -30 minutes.
Posted 2 years ago by Abe C.
Took an hour and 45 minutes. Horrible service. They have no idea how to be efficient with their deliveries. It's a bagel! An hour and 45 is ridiculous!!!!!
Posted 2 years ago by Samira P.
DISGUSTING! Ordered a fried egg sandwich with cheddar on a bagel. It came with BACON! I'm a vegetarian. So gross!!!! I intentionally left the meat option blank, but they took the liberty of assuming that I would like bacon. Awful.
Posted 2 years ago by Teresa H.
PLEASE READ BEFORE YOU ORDER: The site says the delivery time is 50-65 minutes. The email confirmation I received stated 65-80 minutes. 1 hour and 30 minutes later.... Still waiting for a BAGEL?!?! I don't usually write reviews but this is ridiculous!
Posted 2 years ago by Rioko K.
I ordered two eggs over easy with American cheese on top, home fries and a wheat bagel. This meal was PERFECT. Very tasty!!
Posted 2 years ago by Arielle A.
Pretty decent omelette and bagel.
Posted 2 years ago by Rahul P.
Love this place! Sometimes it takes a bit to get here, but they have never gotten my order wrong and they scoop your bagels for you!! Yum.
Posted 2 years ago by Abby W.
Food was average - nothing particularly special about it, but nothing particularly bad either. Getting 2 stars for a couple reasons.
A)The eggs on my breakfast sandwich were scrambled, which is not how i requested them.
B)They forgot an item (which I was charged for). Might seem nitpicky to some, but I'm getting increasingly sick of incorrect orders via restaurants - this was not a special request, or something minute, it was right there in the order options for the item I selected.
C) I paid 1.50 for a slice of turkey on my sandwich - a single slice. I understand Manhattan is expensive, but 1.50 for a single slice of turkey is price gouging, even for time square.
Had my order been correct, I'd likely order again. Since it wasn't, I'll just move on to one of the other myriad options available to me.
Posted 2 years ago by Steven B.
Good food, but (A) they won't toast bagels for delivery (wtf?) and after delivering our food quickly, we discovered the order was wrong. Called them. Super friendly. Said they would fix it right away. Took them twice as long to bring the correct order. I live two blocks away. No thanks.
Posted 2 years ago by matthew d.
i'm addicted - their cream cheese are SO GOOD - delivery takes a while (over an hour) but sooo worth the wait.. just order early/ahead of time.
Posted 2 years ago by charlotte U.
Never get the dressing mixed in. WAY too much. Gross.
Posted 2 years ago by Zach M.
Our favorite bagels. Great baked salmon salad, and "create your own salads". Fast delivery.
Posted 2 years ago by Charlene F.
Delivery is always on time.
Posted 2 years ago by Alex D.
I usually love pick a bagel but this is one of the first times I've done delivery through them. I can't have regular cream cheese and therefore tofu cream cheese is the only thing I can have. When they delivered the wrong type of cream cheese, I called and told them but they insisted that they gave me the right one. I kept saying I know the difference but they insisted that they were right. Thankfully, they are sending another batch over as long as I return the other one. Regardless of who is right or wrong, I thought they way they went around their customer service and trying to help my problem was very rude. I don't think I will order from them again simply because of how rude they were in handling my issue
Posted 2 years ago by Naomi S.
The food NEVER came. It was supposed to arrive in 15-30 minutes, but I never received it. I called the restaurant and they had lost my order. They were completely confused and disorganized. I asked them to cancel my order, but was still charged. I'm now working through Seamless to get reimbursed.
Posted 2 years ago by erin f.
I've been ordering the Greek omelet for breakfast. it tastes great, comes with a bagel or other bread choices. Reasonable delivery time. They have always gotten my order right.
Posted 2 years ago by Amanda C.
food was good and delivery was very fast
Posted 2 years ago by THEO B.
My food arrived cold an hour after ordering. Super cold. It also was the wrong bagel. I called to complain, they re-sent more food. I found it odd that they wanted the previous food back, but I dug it out of the trash anyway. The new food was ice cold again. And the bacon wasn't cooked completely. But the bagel was right.
Posted 2 years ago by Melanie C.
Wrong order delivered after waiting over 90 minutes for delivery. Couldn't get someone to answer the phone for over an hour. Terrible.
Posted 3 years ago by Amelia N.
They had great salads, but just took most of the proteins off the menu and the pasta too. Too bad.
Posted 3 years ago by Susannah H.
My order was late and wrong. I was told I wouldn't be charged for it and I was.
Posted 3 years ago by Kelly M.
Food was outside of the 50 min delivery window. I called and they were very unfriendly and unapologetic and said they were busy. First and last time I'll order from them.
Posted 3 years ago by Eric Y.
They wrote on my food with permanent marker. I threw it up and they did not care. Staff is rude. DO NOT EAT HERE
Posted 3 years ago by Michael S.
Food is awesome as the cheese on the egg sandwiches melts in a particularly scrumptous way. Bagels are also good to quite good. HOWEVER! It takes so much damn time for them to show up with the food which irks me. Fin.
Posted 3 years ago by Kris W.
Delivery up to 50 mins...it was 65. And my food was COLD!! Sorry, no more Pick A Bagel for me.
Posted 3 years ago by tabitha f.
Thought it would be good because it has a four star rating, but the food was absolute yuck.
Posted 3 years ago by Bennett G.
I typically don't leave reviews - sometimes it's just a bad day. But 1hr+ to get a bagel?! Who will ever wait for that again?
Posted 3 years ago by Jonathan L.
Posted 3 years ago by Adam T.
Really quality bagels. The delivery estimate was 45 minutes and the guy showed up in 20.
Posted 3 years ago by Peter W.
asked and paid for my sandwich on a hero. definitely did not get a hero..
Posted 3 years ago by Adam Y.
Service is horrendous. It took over an hour to get here via delivery. We called at 12:02pm to see where it was and the woman said "it just left." Didn't get here until 1:05pm. Unacceptable
Posted 3 years ago by Ali G.
They always, always, always get the orders wrong.
Posted 3 years ago by Dylan H.
Terrible service. Didn't deliver for 1.5 hours, charged my card and said it's Seamless's fault when it clearly wasn't (they knew my address). had to talk to them for 10 minutes and then talk to their manager to finally get my order delivered
Posted 3 years ago by David L.
Terrible service. The food came a full hour and a half after i placed the order and it was completely cold!
Posted 3 years ago by Sabina W.
Best breakfast delivery (and more) in NYC
Posted 4 years ago by John C.
Food is okay, but will never order delivery again. I've waited an hour for two sandwiches...
Posted 4 years ago by Andrew T.
waiting now for an hour...
Posted 4 years ago by Pauline F.
food arrived late and was cold
Posted 4 years ago by rudy b.
Order was not precise. Some of the bagels that arrived were not the flavor that I ordered.
Posted 4 years ago by Karen S.
Always fresh, always good.
Posted 4 years ago by Heath P.
great bagels...extra friendly staff....not one complaint!
bacon, egg and cheese...extra cheese, extra bacon...delicious,
nova...best i've found
tofu scallion cream cheese...again, best i've eaten
knishes and cappuccino muffins also noteworthy
Posted 4 years ago by Anna W.
Great bagels, indecent prices.
Posted 4 years ago by Lior B.
Consistently get the order wrong. Accidentally ordered form this location, versus the Times Sq. location and remembered why I stopped ordering from this location.
Posted 4 years ago by Allen A.
HORRIBLE. WOST SANDWICH I HAVE EVER HAD
Posted 4 years ago by David S.
I had previously liked their egg salad sandwich but when I reordered it the fresh squeezed OJ had spilled all over the bag so I had no OJ and OJ flavored egg salad. disgusting. I was too hungry to wait for a replacement so insisted they refund me. It was not an easy accomplishment! They tried to give me a credit for next time, tried to insist they send a replacement; I had to speak to the manager, Marom, just to get my refund, after being left on hold for almost 10 minutes. Good grief!
Posted 5 years ago by Carmen O.
Ordered a roast beef sandwich on a bagel.
By far the most disgusting "roast beef" I have ever seen. I called and asked if perhaps their roast beef is old or if there was another explanation. They insisted it was good roast beef.
Needless to say will never order from this place again.
Posted 5 years ago by Andy U.
I ordered the platter and it only came as a sandwich, so I didn't get the tomatoes, onion and cucumber I was craving. Also they substituted a Sunkist for my Organgina which to me is not comparable. Food took over an hour for delivery. Won't be ordering from here again.
Posted 5 years ago by Nicole L.
Posted 5 years ago by Jordan R.
best bagels you'll find on here (no H&H available)
Posted 5 years ago by Gary M.
Ordered at 9am and took almost TWO HOURS to get here. Would never order delivery again, which is sad, since they have the best hc and bagels!
Posted 6 years ago by Leighann S.
Always on time- orders are flawless- bagels are chewy and wonderful! What more could I ask?
Posted 7 years ago by Elizabeth M.
great breakfast place, terrible for lunch
Posted 7 years ago by Elvis V.
I have ordered from this place 2 times now and they have yet to remember any dressing or sugar for my coffee. Needless to say, I do not suggest anyone uses seamless for Pick A Bagel.
Posted 7 years ago by Dana C.
I order 3 bottles of 20oz Dr. Pepper. I got 3 cans (12oz.) of soda, but was charged the full amount. They should have adjusted the price which they did not.
Posted 7 years ago by Bulent O.
They advertise Pepsi, but always deliver Coke. Annoying!
Posted 7 years ago by Chris R.
They are the slowest (and most forgetful) delivery people of all time. I've had to cancel multiple orders because they've been so late. They absolutely suck.
Posted 8 years ago by Nicholas O.
By far the best Lox, Sable and White fish platter on Seamless web.
Posted 8 years ago by Bernard W.
This order was not filled correctly and no one called me to tell me of the change.
When I called manager was rude. What happened to customer service?
Posted 8 years ago by Linda K.
Food is good, but they need to arrive quicker with it and get order right. I hate getting a diet snapple by accident.
Posted 8 years ago by Geoffrey C.
Good bagels, but they almost consistently deliver the order incorrectly -- very frustrating
Posted 8 years ago by Glenn R J.
I ordered two bagels and a diet snapple. They brought the wrong snapple, a juice instead of a tea. The only brought one of the bagels, sesame w/ butter. The other was delivered almost an hour later and the same type of bagel w/ peanut butter was so hard and stale I couldn't eat it and threw it in the garbage. I feel like they did it on purpose because they had to come back. The other day the delivery person was very rude when I asked to see the receipt for a second time.
Posted 8 years ago by Dana M.
Only select user reviews are published on Seamless. All user-submitted ratings contribute to Pick a Bagel's overall Seamless rating, but we manually screen all reviews and only publish those that are relevant and helpful. Tips for getting your review published »
Above content provided by restaurant.
Order online from
Pick a Bagel by entering your address
below. Online ordering powered by Seamless.com.
Return users log
Click a menu item to add it to your order.
Back to top
Seamless North America, LLC. All Rights Reserved.
0808 234 7862
Seamless North America, LLC. All Rights Reserved.